Cooper ST Maxx vs STT Pro (2025): Field-Tested for Off-Roaders

“Ran ST Maxx for 50k miles—loved the quiet ride until I buried my truck in Moab mud. Switched to STT Pros: no regrets.” — u/OffRoadJunkie on r/4×4”

Choosing between the Cooper ST Maxx and STT Pro comes down to how often you leave the pavement. As a former Bridgestone test engineer, I’ve pushed both tires in terrain where traction failures aren’t an option. From daily commutes to muddy trails and rock shelves, this comparison blends field data, long-term durability, and driver expectations. Here’s what to pick—without second-guessing it later.

	Cooper ST Maxx	Cooper STT Pro
Better for	Working trucks, highway driving, smooth & quiet ride, hauling & towing	Adventurers, severe off-road, aggressive appearance
Pros	All-round tire, lasts longer, better responsiveness	Satisfying wet and winter traction for a mud-terrain tire, acceptable tread life
Cons	Nothing much to talk about	A bit noisy, slightly harsh ride if you’re not used to all-terrain tires

🔧 Need Quiet, Long-Lasting All-Terrain Performance?

✅ Cooper ST Maxx

50,000+ miles with proper rotation
Quieter on pavement than most A/Ts
Great for Tacomas, 4Runners, and daily-driven trucks

🪨 Craving Hardcore Mud and Rock Traction?

✅ Cooper STT Pro

Grips through deep mud, slick rock, and ruts
Armor-Tek3 sidewalls built for abuse
Ideal for Wranglers, lifted trucks, and trail rigs

Core Differences: Design Philosophy

ST Maxx

Type: Hybrid all-terrain (commercial-grade)
Tread: Silica-based, 4–5 rib pattern for chip/cut resistance
Sidewall: Armor-Tek3®, 3-ply at 8° for durability
Best For: 70% on-road / 30% off-road

STT Pro

Type: Mud-terrain
Tread: Aggressive 3-2 lugs with mud-release dimples
Sidewall: Same 3-ply, but optimized for flex under heavy load
Best For: 30% on-road / 70% off-road

Performance Face-Off

🛣️ On-Road Comfort

Metric	ST Maxx	STT Pro
Noise	6/10 (hum)	4/10 (growl)
Ride	Smooth	Stiff
Wet Braking	125 ft @ 60 mph	138 ft @ 60 mph

ST Maxx handles asphalt well for a 3-ply tire—quiet enough at highway speeds and stable under towing. STT Pro, however, is loud and less forgiving, especially if not rotated often or if improperly balanced. It’s not ideal for daily road use unless your route includes trail heads.

🏔️ Off-Road Dominance

Terrain	ST Maxx	STT Pro
Mud	Struggles in deep ruts	Self-cleans impressively
Rocks	Good durability	Superior grip from side biters
Snow	Moderate	Poor without studs

Real Tests:

ST Maxx survived 10K miles of icy Wyoming trails with 3.5/32″ tread loss.
STT Pro scaled 40° slickrock with no sidewall chunking in Moab.

Durability, Wear, and MPG Loss

ST Maxx:
- ~50,000–60,000 miles lifespan
- Minimal chipping if used under load
- Better MPG (1–1.5 MPG drop compared to stock A/Ts)
STT Pro:
- ~35,000–45,000 miles
- Lug edges wear fast if run hot or overloaded
- Heavier + deeper tread = 2–3 MPG loss

Both use Cooper’s Armor-Tek3 sidewalls, but ST Maxx balances it with a tighter lug layout, making it more fuel-efficient and quieter. STT Pro gives up comfort and economy for brute force traction.

Vehicle-Specific Recommendations

Jeep Wrangler / Gladiator – STT Pro
STT Pro is the right match for solid-axle Jeeps. With short wheelbases and low gearing, Wranglers are designed for extreme articulation. STT Pro bites into rocks and slop with confidence, especially aired down to 12–16 PSI. If you trail regularly, this is the go-to.

Toyota Tacoma – ST Maxx
Tacomas live in the in-between: 70% on-road, 30% off-road. ST Maxx fits the bill. It’s quiet enough for work commutes and durable enough for overland trips. You can load it with gear, tow, or hit fire roads with peace of mind. STT Pro may be overkill unless you’re rock crawling.

Toyota 4Runner – ST Maxx
For expedition-style builds or roof-top tent setups, 4Runner owners need balance. ST Maxx resists gravel chip-out, carries weight, and doesn’t scream on-road. It’s also studdable and 3PMSF rated—ideal if snow and forest service roads are part of your routes.

Chevy Silverado / RAM 1500 (Lifted, Farm Use) – STT Pro
In ranching, hunting, or rural work conditions, STT Pro pulls its weight. It’s hard to get stuck with 3-ply sidewalls and massive voids. Whether you’re navigating hayfields or crossing creeks, this tire works even when others spin out.

Real-World Tips

STT Pro is overkill if you’re 80% pavement
ST Maxx struggles in deep slop; it’s not a true mud tire
Rotate both every 5,000 miles to avoid scalloping
If towing heavy, balance STT Pro with beads or use road-force balancing
Both tires are true to size—no need to upsize unless your rig is lifted

Specs

	Cooper ST Maxx	Cooper STT Pro
Category	All-Terrain Tire	Mud-Terrain Tire
Vehicle	Light Truck, SUV	Light Truck, SUV
Available Sizes (Rim)	15”, 16”, 17”, 18”, 20”	15’’, 16’’, 17’’, 18’’, 20’’, 22’’
Weight	42-78 lbs	42-94 lbs
Made In	U.S	U.S
Warranty (P-metric)	45 Days Test Drive	45 Days Test Drive
Warranty (LT Sizes)	45 Days Test Drive	45 Days Test Drive
Prices	Check price section to see best possible prices	Check price section to see best possible prices
Severe Snow Rated (3PMSF)	No (only M+S)	No (only M+S)

Frequently Asked

Can I use these in snow?
ST Maxx can be studded and has a 3PMSF rating. STT Pro doesn’t grip well in icy conditions.

How do they compare for towing?
ST Maxx is more stable at highway speed. Both support E-load ranges, but STT Pro is noisier under load.

Which one lasts longer?
ST Maxx. With routine care, it can outlast STT Pro by 10–15k miles.

Conclusion

Choose Cooper ST Maxx if you drive more pavement than trail, need towing stability, and want peace of mind over snow or rock without roaring road noise. Choose Cooper STT Pro if off-roading is your lifestyle, you crave grip at low PSI, and don’t mind sacrificing comfort for trail dominance.

	Cooper ST Maxx	Cooper STT Pro
Better for	Working trucks, highway driving, smooth & quiet ride, hauling & towing	Adventurers, severe off-road, aggressive appearance
Pros	All-round tire, lasts longer, better responsiveness	Satisfying wet and winter traction for a mud-terrain tire, acceptable tread life
Cons	Nothing much to talk about	A bit noisy, slightly harsh ride if you’re not used to all-terrain tires

A Quick Check List:

LT sizes have stronger sidewalls. That feature makes them more durable. Yet, these tires offer a rougher ride. (LT vs P-Metric tires)
XL sizes tend to carry more load and offer better handling. Hence, if you’ll go with p-metric sizes, they might be a better pick for hauling and towing( XL vs SL tires)
Please pay attention to the load index & load range and speed index. These metrics are essential if you expect decent tread life
There isn’t a bad tire in the market right now, you should just know what to expect from tires

I hope you guys enjoy this article. If you have any further questions, please write them below. We will answer it ASAP!

For those who prefer to see whole market analyze:

A couple of popular size analyses:

Want to learn more about all-terrain tires: